Can a Futures Trade Be Cancelled After It Fills?
Under CME Group's Rule 588 the exchange adjusts the price of a futures trade that printed outside the product's non-reviewable range, and may cancel it instead where several parties, prices or contracts are involved; price banding is the separate check that runs before a trade matches.

Yes. A matched futures trade on CME Globex can be cancelled, and it can also be repriced, by the exchange's Global Command Center under Rule 588, which CME titles Trade Cancellations and Price Adjustments. For a futures trade priced outside the product's non-reviewable range, the rule's remedy is an adjusted price, and cancellation is the alternative the rule holds back for a tangle of parties, prices or contracts.
Can a futures trade be cancelled after it fills?
A filled futures trade is not necessarily final. In the text CME filed with the CFTC on 1 October 2020 for itself and for CBOT, NYMEX and COMEX, Rule 588 hands the Global Command Center — the GCC — discretion to reprice or cancel, where it judges the step needed to contain a market-disrupting event caused by misuse of the electronic trading system, by a mistake made on it, or by a defect in it.
The GCC works in two steps. It decides first whether a trade is reviewed at all, and only then analyses the price under Rule 588.C. For a futures contract, including a futures spread, a price found outside the non-reviewable range is adjusted to fair value at the moment of the trade, plus or minus that range. Cancellation enters where an incident is tangled. CME's filing says that with multiple parties, prices or contracts involved, the GCC has the "authority, but not the obligation, to cancel rather than price adjust such transactions". Either way the GCC issues an alert saying what it has done.
CME's client documentation describes the same power from the message side. It says CME Globex sends a cancellation when CME Group determines that an executed trade took place outside the product's price band, or deems it a rulebook violation for any other reason.
What is the non-reviewable range in futures trading?
The non-reviewable range is the distance either side of fair value inside which a reviewed trade is left alone. Rule 588.C as filed in October 2020 puts it plainly: if the GCC finds the price of a reviewed trade inside the range, it issues an alert and the trade stands. Outside the range, the futures price becomes fair value at the time of the trade, plus or minus the range.
Options are measured differently. In the text as filed, the GCC's first test for an option is the Bid/Ask Reasonability Allowance, which the rule defines as the widest bid/ask range that will be treated as reasonable when setting the parameters for that option's non-reviewable range. The stated aim of the 2020 amendment was to harmonise options with the existing futures process, and the covering letter sets the options range at the greater of three measures: delta multiplied by the underlying futures range, 20% of premium capped at a quarter of that range, or two or five minimum price increments depending on how liquid the contract is. The exchanges explained the older two-step test as a response to thin on-screen liquidity in Globex options when it was adopted.
The numbers are in neither the 2020 filing nor the 2016 one. The ranges sit in the Rule 588.H table, Globex Non-Reviewable Trading Ranges, which both of those filings attach as an exhibit under separate cover. The range is set for the product, so the current rulebook is where to read the one for the contract you trade.
How does the exchange decide what the price should have been?
It determines a fair value market price for the contract as at the instant the reviewed trade happened. Rule 588.C leaves the evidence open: the GCC may consider any relevant information, and the list it gives is explicitly not exhaustive. Among the inputs named are the state of the market at that moment, and the contract's own last trade or a better quote on either side of the book.
Four more appear on the list. A fresher print in another contract month. A price for the same contract, or a related one, established in another venue or market. An option's theoretical value off its latest implied volatility. And the answers that came back to a request for quote. The list reaches past the contract's own screen, leaving the GCC something to work with in a thinly traded month.
The official record is then corrected. Under the same subsection, both a cancelled price and an adjusted one are struck from the exchange's official time and sales record, and the repriced trade is then written back into that record at the price it was given. For an option outside its range the adjustment has a direction: a buy error is moved to the determined ask price from the Bid/Ask Reasonability Allowance plus the non-reviewable range, and a sell error to the determined bid minus it.
Who pays when the exchange cancels or adjusts a trade?
The party that entered the order pays an administrative fee to the exchange, charged for each occurrence. Rule 588.G, the Schedule of Administrative Fees, was amended in a filing dated 11 April 2016 and effective for trade date 26 April 2016, which raised that fee from $500 to $1,000.
The rule also names a backstop. Where the responsible party falls outside Rule 400's definition of a Member and does not pay, the fee lands on the clearing member the trade was placed through. In the same letter the exchanges dated the original $500 fee to 2009, described its purpose as marking the effect that a cancelled or adjusted trade has on market integrity and on other participants, and said the number of erroneous trades cancelled or adjusted had fallen steadily since it was introduced — a claim they made without publishing a figure.
A rule filing is the rule as submitted on its date, so treat $1,000 as the 2016 amount and check the current rulebook before relying on it. The 2016 filing also folded the fee into the Rule 588.H table for easier reference, so that table carries both the fee and the ranges.
Can the two sides of an error trade agree on something else?
Sometimes, with the GCC's approval. Rule 588.D, Alternative Resolution by Agreement of Parties, was amended in a CBOT filing dated 2 May 2023 and effective 17 May 2023, and it starts by closing the door on trades inside the non-reviewable range: where the GCC finds the price inside the range, the parties have no alternative action available under the rule.
Outside the range, the amended subsection allows the two sides to swap one remedy for the other in either direction. With GCC approval, parties to a price-adjusted trade may agree to cancel it instead, and parties to a cancelled trade may agree to reprice it to a figure that squares with how subsection C would have adjusted it. They may also agree a cash adjustment, provided they report it to the GCC and keep a record of it.
Reversing a trade by transferring the position is the route the 2023 amendment narrowed. A transfer is permitted only where the GCC determines the trade was outside the non-reviewable range but was not reported in time, and then only with both parties' agreement and the GCC's approval, at the original trade price and quantity, with a cash adjustment available by mutual agreement. A trade that was not cancelled cannot be unwound through a prearranged offsetting transaction except as Rule 539.C permits. The filing also points to Rule 853 for transfers and Rule 527 for execution errors on Globex.
What is price banding, and why does it reject an order?
Price banding is the pre-trade price check on CME Globex. Every order is validated against a band around a reference price, and an order priced outside the band is rejected before it can trade. CME's documentation gives the test as a buy priced over the Last Price by more than the product's band value, or a sell priced under it by the same distance, and describes the purpose as stopping hostile or mistyped prices from printing market-moving trades that then have to be cancelled.
The fixed value is the Price Band Variation, a static figure that varies by product and is applied symmetrically above and below the reference price to form the Price Band Variation Range. That range is recalculated with every price change and enforced through the session. Which reference price applies depends on the market state: settlement while the market is in pre-open, including the no-cancel stretch at its end; the indicative opening price once one has been calculated; and the Globex Last Price through continuous trading. If neither an indicative opening price nor a Last Price was ever established, the settlement price keeps the job.
Can the exchange widen or switch off a price band?
Yes. Bands on CME Globex are maintained through the session: CME's documentation says the GCC monitors the ranges and may adjust them, and that CME Group may temporarily relax or suspend banding when prices move rapidly. Daily trading limits take priority over the band for rejecting erroneous prices, and for a product with limits or circuit breakers those can stop order entry first, which is the subject of how price limits work on futures contracts. Banding also leaves a great deal alone: bids below the market, offers above it, and how far from the market a trader chooses to work an order. Because the band tracks the last trade or the best quote, entering orders beyond it moves the band, which is why CME says banding will not lock up a fast market.
CME publishes a test scenario in which the band widens on a group-level multiplier. Against a pre-open reference of 2000.00, a bid at 3975 and an offer at 49 are both rejected with the multiplier at 2, and both accepted with it at 3.
Does price banding apply to market orders and stop orders?
Not in the same way. CME's documentation says banding does not affect market orders and will not prevent one from being entered, because a market order can only match to the best opposing quote and not past it. In its worked example, a 100-lot market limit buy takes the 25 lots offered at the best price and the remaining 75 is then handled as a limit bid at that same price.
What banding does catch is the conversion. Where a market order is turned into a limit order outside the host, at a price that would run through the book, CME's documentation says the order is rejected.
Stops are measured against the banding parameter at entry. If the stop's limit price sits farther from the trigger price than the parameter allows, the order is rejected, and CME draws the consequence itself: for every accepted stop order, a triggered stop's limit will be at a price inside the band. That is a different check from the one that decides how a triggered stop behaves, which is covered in stop loss versus stop limit orders in futures.
How do price banding, daily price limits and the non-reviewable range differ?
Three separate mechanisms sit between a mistyped price and a settled trade, and they act at different moments. Banding and daily limits work on orders before anything matches. The non-reviewable range only matters once a trade exists and the GCC has decided to review it.
| Price banding | Daily price limits | Non-reviewable range | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it tests | An incoming order's price against a band around a reference price | Whether a price is within the session's permitted move | An executed trade's price against fair value |
| When it acts | Before the order can trade | Before the order can trade | After the trade has matched and been selected for review |
| What happens | The order is rejected | A price outside the limits cannot trade, and order entry may be blocked, though in most products a GTC or GTD may rest inactive until price comes back inside | Inside: the trade stands. Outside: the price is adjusted, and the GCC may cancel instead where multiple parties, prices or contracts are involved |
| Who sets it | A per-product Price Band Variation, monitored and adjustable by the GCC | The exchange, for certain contracts, with intra-session recalculation by the Daily Limit Adjustment program | The Rule 588.H table, applied by the GCC |
| Where the values live | CME's Globex Product Reference Sheet | The exchange's limits for that contract, which for physical commodities come off in the delivery month | The Rule 588.H table |
What this means on a simulated funded account
Every account here is simulated and trades on live market data, where the prices are real and fills follow real market conditions, so the mechanics above are the ones behind the prices you read.
Not every rejected order is an exchange matter, though. Our own contract limits live in the platform, and an order for more contracts than your account size carries never reaches a price check at all.
What the rules above are worth to you is mostly timing. On a funded or evaluation account the drawdown line is monitored in real time and touching it liquidates the account at once, so any position you cannot close when you want to is a position still exposed to that line. The check worth making before the session rather than during it is that a stop's limit price sits no farther from its trigger than the product's banding parameter allows, since that is the test the exchange applies at entry. Where nothing was rejected and the fill simply came in worse than you wanted, the subject is slippage and a separate problem.
FAQ
Why was my futures order rejected for being outside the price band?
Because CME Globex price-validates every order and rejects one priced beyond the band around its reference price: a buy more than the product's band value over the Last Price, or a sell the same distance under it. The band value varies by product, and the reference price changes with the market state: settlement in the pre-open, the indicative opening price once one exists, then the Globex Last Price in continuous trading. The range is recalculated on every price change, so where the band sits moves through the session.
Does a cancelled futures trade stay in the price record?
No. Rule 588.C as filed in 2020 strikes both kinds of price — the cancelled one and the adjusted one — from the exchange's official time and sales record, and writes the repriced trade back in at the figure it was given. On the message side, CME's client documentation describes the cancellation arriving as an execution report carrying an order status and an execution type of H.
Will the exchange cancel a futures trade just because I lost money on it?
Nothing in the three rule filings cited here ties the GCC's power to a trader's profit or loss. Rule 588 ties it instead to containing market disruption caused by misuse of the electronic trading system, a mistake on it, or a defect in it. The first test on review is whether the price sat inside the non-reviewable range; if it did, the trade stands. Rule 588.D, as amended in 2023, adds that inside that range the parties have no alternative action available to them either.
Does price banding protect me from slippage?
Not from slippage inside the book. CME's documentation says banding does not affect market orders, since a market order reaches only the best opposing quote, and that an unfilled remainder is then handled as a limit at that price. What banding rejects is an order whose price would run through the book from outside the host. What caps the price range a contract is allowed in one session is a daily price limit, which the exchange sets for certain contracts.
Sources
- CME Submission No. 20-049 to the CFTC, 1 October 2020 — amendments to CME/CBOT/NYMEX/COMEX Rule 588.C. (Price Adjustments and Cancellations) and the Rule 588.H. table
- CME Submission No. 16-133 to the CFTC, 11 April 2016 — amendments to Rule 588.G. (Schedule of Administrative Fees)
- CBOT Submission No. 23-119 to the CFTC, 2 May 2023 — amendments to Rule 588.D. (Alternative Resolution by Agreement of Parties)
- CME Group Client Systems Wiki — Limits and Banding (page 457317722)
- CME Group Client Systems Wiki — GCC Price Banding (page 457320464)
- CME Group Client Systems Wiki — iLink - Trade Cancellation (page 457096410)
Educational content about futures markets and simulated trading. Not investment advice, and not a solicitation to trade. Trading futures involves substantial risk of loss. Read the full risk disclosure.